collision detection
content | discontent
send me yours
February 15, 2005
How to talk when you can't speak: My latest Slate column

Last week, a report in Neurology outlined some rather disturbing findings: Apparently, supposedly "minimally conscious" brain-injury patients may be far more conscious than we realize. The scientists located two men who'd suffered terrible brain injuries, leaving them able to breathe on their own but otherwise unresponsive. Then the played them audiotapes of their loved ones relating cherished stories from their past. The result? The men's brain activity was amazingly close to that of "normal", fully-conscious people -- and one of the men even had high levels of visual-cortex activity, indicating that he was perhaps visualizing the memories. If this study holds water, we may need to radically rethink how we deal with the minimally conscious -- who are often abandoned and left with almost no stimulus.

Better yet, is there any way to communicate with them? This is the subject I tackled in my latest Slate column, where I looked at the state of "brain computer interfaces". An example:

One promising technique for unlocking the thoughts of paralyzed patients is to hook them up to electroencephalograms. EEGs read the electrical impulses caused by brain activity, including the "P300 wave," something like an involuntary "aha" response. When you're looking at a set of items and see something you suddenly recognize, your brain automatically kicks out an electrical spike 300 milliseconds later. You don't have to think about it; it just happens.

Psychologists Lawrence Farwell and Emanuel Donchin have turned this response into a rudimentary typing machine. The patient gets hooked up to an EEG, then looks at a computer screen that shows a six-by-six grid of the letters of the alphabet. When he focuses on a certain letter, the computer begins highlighting each column. As the column containing the chosen letter comes up, the subject's brain spits out a P300 "aha" response. When the computer repeats the same thing with the rows and gets another "aha," it gets the X and Y coordinates for the correct letter. Using this technique, people with ALS can "type" about four letters per minute. Best of all, because the "aha" response happens automatically, they don't have to learn any new skills.

You can read the rest of the piece online here for free -- and if you've any thoughts on it, feel free to post in The Fray, Slate's comment area, where intelligent discussion is always welcome!

Posted by Clive Thompson at February 15, 2005 01:38 AM | TrackBack
Comments

I haven't read the piece yet -- I'm responding to your word "disturbing."

Need I point out that for anyone who has a loved one in a coma or some state similar to that, this is fabulously good news? This is what you hope is happening. Isn't it? I guess being trapped inside a lifeless body could be pretty bad, hellish, etc. -- but when you stand over your comatose bride, groom, mother, son-- you're hoping he or she hears and understands you.

Right?

Posted by: Martin on February 15, 2005 04:43 PM

Absolutely, that makes sense! However, my use of "disturbing" was intended to refer to the fact that a great majority of the minimally-conscious are presumed to be in a vegetative state, and are left with no stimulation at all. If they're actually more conscious than that, this is tantamount to horrid neglect -- and is indeed quite disturbing.

Posted by: Clive on February 15, 2005 05:11 PM

Caisse

Posted by: Mister on March 5, 2005 12:07 AM

http://searchupme.com/fastin/

Fastin, diette pills,

Posted by: Faston on March 6, 2005 01:41 AM

uk live web cams - free sexwebcams web cam sex live free no credit card naked web cam girls - webcam video teen chat world - amature webcam web cam adult web cams 4 free - webcam tits web cam hot sexy girls - adult sexcams webcam videochat girls - webcam movies teenage girls on webcam - webcam girls xxx russia cam - sexcam heaven web cam live stripper girls - free sexcam weather web cams - webcams girls webcam categories girls strapon tpg - webcams free web cam ejculate girl masturbating - florida webcam webcams web cam girls - webcams girls live australia outback web cams - amateur webcam personal webcams webcam girls - webcam pornfree live sex chat and cams - webcam swingers live nude adult web cams girls web cam live free - sex webcam live view austrailian web cams - webcam pictures sex sex cam espana - webcam swingers lists of private web cams in the netherlands - webcam pics secret friends web cam - webcam topless ontario adult chat rooms - amature webcams live mature adult web cams - webcam capture spanking live webcams - sexcam shows local xxx chat - adult cams private nude cams - adult cam personels adult web cams top home cams - webcam girls sex live web cams free - webcam pictures live adult cam streaming web cam - webcam spy saturday night live video clips - sex webcams live sex webcam channel free - amature webcam live local webcam chat - amateur webcam online webcam chat - free pornwebcams sex rooms totally free adult chat - free webcams live airport webcams ohio web cams - active webcam porn free acess adult web cams - free webcamchat live webcams free webcam - webcams girls spy cams of lesbians haveing sex - webcam movies live adult chat streaming webcams - webcam sexy sorirty girls web cam - free livevideo live ladies web cams - webcam girl paypal sites sex cams - webcam review live adult webcam amateur - sexcams free sex chat adult free web cams - webcam free live streaming animal web cams - webcam topless singles teen flirt chat - erotic webcams live online video - sexcam shows lesbians caught having sex on web cams - free chatvoicewebcam live asian girl web cams - webcam voyeur live xxx cam sample - free sexcams live webcams any webcam - webcamgirls
H3l0-Hello guys! I love this blog!-H3l0

Posted by: Live cams on March 13, 2005 08:25 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?