FREE counter and Web statistics from sitetracker.com
collision detection
content | discontent
send me yours
January 18, 2008
"Natural" rivers are actually man-made














This is fascinating: Apparently geologists have spent decades assuming that the shapes of Mid-Atlantic-state rivers were natural -- when they're actually man-made.

Basically, one of the problems with studying rivers in the US is that so many have been warped by commercial and residential development that it's hard for us to know what the stream ought to look like, naturally. The closest to "natural" that the geologists could identify were rivers of the mid-Atlantic states -- which move in ribbon-like channels through silty banks. They assumed, for decades, that this ribbon-like shape was the Platonic solid.

But it turns out that those ribbon-straight rivers were in fact affected by human development, as two scientists -- Robert C. Walter and Dorothy J. Merritts -- report in Science today. As the New York Times reports:

In a telephone interview, Dr. Merritts described a typical scenario. Settlers build a dam across a valley to power a grist mill, and a pond forms behind the dam, inundating the original valley wetland. Meanwhile, the settlers clear hillsides for farming, sending vast quantities of eroded silt washing into the pond.

Years go by. The valley bottom fills with sediment trapped behind the dam. By 1900 or so the dam is long out of use and eventually fails. Water begins to flow freely through the valley again. But now, instead of reverting to branching channels moving over and through extensive valley wetlands, the stream cuts a sharp path through accumulated sediment. This is the kind of stream that earlier researchers thought was natural.

"This early work was excellent," Dr. Merritts said, "but it was done unknowingly in breached millponds."


(Image above by Fhantazm, via his Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike license!)

Posted by Clive Thompson at January 18, 2008 09:07 AM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.collisiondetection.net/mt3/mt-tb.cgi/1726

Comments

This story -- even moreso the photo that leads it -- reminds me of something that struck me a few years back. My parents retired to a beautiful piece of land in Nova Scotia that backs onto a lake. The treed path that follows a babbling brook, descending to the lake shore, is a small patch of natural beauty -- the kind that lifts your spirit, makes you feel you've left the artificial world of human enterprise, a return to nature. But when I looked more carefully, I saw my father's hand everywhere: rocks moved to contain the stream, underbrush cleared between the trees, overhanging branches and thorns cut away from the path.

What we humans consider natural, even instinctively, is a nature shaped by our hands. Real untouched nature is hostile, impenetrable, and opaque. The swampy wetlands describe above, presumable insect-infested and boggy, not the "natural" stream that deceived the first set of scientists.

Posted by: Peter [TypeKey Profile Page] at January 23, 2008 11:23 AM

Peter, aweseome story ... that's a great illustration of the point!

Posted by: Clive [TypeKey Profile Page] at January 29, 2008 10:54 AM

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

NOTE: If you posted a comment and you can't see it -- try refreshing your browser.


Remember me?