FREE counter and Web statistics from sitetracker.com
collision detection
content | discontent
send me yours
November 23, 2005
A machinima commentary on the riots in France










Here's an extremely cool project: "The French Democracy", a machinima film about the recent riots in France. It's a little dramatization of the lives of three different black French citizens. One is a teenager who gets apprehended by police and thrown in jail for an evening because he doesn't have his passport on him; another is an MBA graduate who can't find a job because he doesn't look "French" enough; and the third is a drug dealer. Each boils up with rage until they decide to start rioting.

Now, this flick is hardly going to win the Palme d'Or at Cannes. But it's easily one of the most impressive and emotionally affective pieces of machinima I've ever seen. When I was writing my feature this summer for the New York Times Magazine about machinima, I saw a lot of stuff that made me laff, but very little that made me think. This one accomplishes that, not merely because of its unexpectedly heartwarming political message, but because its cinematography has such a weirdly mongrel flavor: It borrows as often from the visual conventions of games as from film.

An example? At different points in the movie, the three main characters stand in the same place on a subway platform, fuming about their plight. Each time, there are characters in the background -- one smoking, one just hanging around -- and each time, although they're different background characters, they're in the exact same places, performing the exact same actions.

As anyone who's played a lot of games knows, one of the funniest -- or most annoying -- elements in sloppily-designed games is that the game designers will simply create three or four basic figure models (a woman, a man, a child) with a few set expressions and movements, and then just replicate them ad infinitum around the world, while "reskinning" them to look individual. The upshot is that you keep on running into the "same" person over and over again, except with different clothes and hair. So there's something lovely about the machinima creator explicitly referencing that in-game problem. It's a clever metaphor that externalizes how the characters in this movie are feeling: Trapped in world where everyone around them is duplicitous, inhuman, and acting suspiciously alike.

There are plenty of other aesthetically nifty things about this movie, not least of which that the creator decided not to use voice-overs; the characters' speech appears as slightly-mangled English along the bottom of the screen. This creates the odd effect of a movie that feels both incredibly new -- it's created using a video game -- and incredibly old: It uses speech-frames straight out of silent movies. Better yet, the guy clearly didn't do this to be selfconciously, superironically retro. He just doesn't speak English very well and couldn't afford voice actors who did. The raw DIY feel of this project is more punk rock than anything anyone's done with music in about 20 years.

Anyway, enough of my jawing. Check this thing out now!


(Thanks to Paul Marino for this one!)

Posted by Clive Thompson at November 23, 2005 07:43 PM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.collisiondetection.net/mt3/mt-tb.cgi/1371

Comments

Wow - I'll have to check this out tonight when I'm not at the office. One question, though: what game is the engine for this machinima? I don't think you mentioned it.

Posted by: Rollen [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 25, 2005 10:31 AM

I believe it's The Sims 2!

Posted by: Clive [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 28, 2005 1:00 PM

It's actually created with The Movies, a game designed for creating in-game movies. There's some controversy over who actually owns the movies created with the game though -- Tony Walsh has details here.

Posted by: Donald Melanson [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 29, 2005 12:44 PM

Aha -- thanks, Donald!

Posted by: Clive [TypeKey Profile Page] at December 1, 2005 7:03 PM

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

NOTE: If you posted a comment and you can't see it -- try refreshing your browser.


Remember me?